Monday, 26 March 2012

NOVEL ANALYSIS 2012 THE PLAYGROUND MAFIA




THE PLAYGROUND MAFIA
Protagonist Caroline Gray
Protagonist single mother of Benjamin, Caroline Gray confronts a group 
of women who intimidate and isolate other mothers who fail to play by 
their rules and live by their values.   Caroline is a gentle character, 
saddened by life, a romantic who doesn’t believe in romance any more, 
and who in many ways, lives vicariously through her son.   She 
understands why mothers become embroiled in playground politics but 
wishes to remain immune to it.

The drama within the novel occurs within the environment of a 
playground and amongst mothers but it could easily occur within other 
environments – the office, the gym, another country, where other 
‘mafias’ (aka bullies) exist and bullying is able to thrive.  The 
playground polarises the bullying and puts it into context – showing 
the behaviour for what it is – nothing more than childhood spats under 
a veneer of sophistication.

For example children may fight in the playground – they get told off by 
the on duty playground teacher.   Or at worst sent to the headmaster.   
When grown ups fight as in this novel, they get sent to prison, to 
court and arrested for GBH.   The novel shows how the ‘grown ups’ may 
have grown older but they have not grown up.

Caroline wants from the onset to keep a low profile, to not be noticed, 
to be a ‘good girl’.   She keeps the company of her friends, one of 
whom is having an extra marital affair and warns her about the bullying 
girls (the mafia).  However, in the defence of her friend she 
unwittingly makes an enemy of the mafia.

Heather is unhappily married, having the affair but is a very loyal 
mother and bored with the mundanity of needing to conform to the 
motherhood tradition of talking to other mothers whom she finds dull.
Eva is anxious about being a good mother and keeping her family 
together, protecting her children and striking the right balance.   She 
is an interesting counterpoint to Caroline’s singledom, and Heather’s 
care free attitude towards her marriage and affair.

The politics of the playground unlike that of the office is 
particularly insidious. Children are observing and absorbing the 
behaviour of the parents so the behaviour is potentially replicated.
Caroline remains true to her conscious throughout the novel, and 
although she meets her ‘cameraman’ who is an observer on life and her 
life in particular, she remains unchanged by the events which occur, 
showing that the politics of the playground takes on far greater 
importance than it needs to – it is ultimately the politics of 
pettiness.

Sarah Flint, the ‘godmother’, Sheila ‘the heavy,’ and Karen, ‘the 
spiteful short side kick’ are typical ‘mean girls’ who rule the roost 
in the playground.   They are every teenage girl’s nightmare and every 
single mum’s nightmare as well.    And they exist in every playground 
in the country.
The novel was hugely successful and continues to be so.  Highly 
competitive parents (hippies – high impact parents) have failed to 
achieve success in their own life and want to achieve it through their 
children. They want their children to succeed but their success is 
nothing to do with their children but an extension of their own 
persona.    Although published in 2006, an app (mummy mafia) 2010, 
stage play 2011 has been produced and numerous articles on the issue of 
playground politics and how to deal with it.   The novel struck a cord 
and continues to do so as parents continue to live vicariously through 
their children and identify their over competitive behaviour as nothing 
more than strategic parenting.



No comments:

Post a Comment